Scientists say tsunami damage on reefs close to the 2004 Sumatra-Andaman earthquake epicenter pales in comparison with human-caused damage.
Researchers from Queensland Australia's James Cook University, the Wildlife Conservation Society-Indonesia Program, and Indonesia's Syiah Kuala University say tsunami damage was occasionally spectacular, but surprisingly limited particularly when compared with damage from chronic human misuse.
Ecologists visited a number of reefs in northern Aceh province. Some of the same reefs were visited in 2003, presenting a unique opportunity to assess the ecological impact of tsunamis on tropical marine ecosystems.
Researchers found direct tsunami damage largely restricted to corals growing in unconsolidated substrata. They found in areas where fishing has been controlled, coral cover was high. In contrast, reefs exposed to fishing had low coral cover and high algal cover -- a change the tsunami might exacerbate in bringing an influx of nutrients and sediments.
However, researchers found no evidence to suggest healthy reefs reduced tsunami-induced damage on land. The authors concluded human modification of the reef environment did not contribute to the magnitude of land damage.
The research is reported in the journal Current Biology.
Copyright 2005 by United Press International
Related stories:
Scientists study 'stealth' tsunami that killed 600 in Java last summer
Though categorized as magnitude 7.8, the earthquake could scarcely be felt by beachgoers that afternoon. A low tide and wind-driven waves disguised the signs of receding water, so when the tsunami struck, it caught even lifeguards by surprise. That contributed to the death toll of more than 600 persons in Java, Indonesia.
Study: Living coral reefs provide better protection from tsunami waves
Healthy coral reefs provide their adjacent coasts with substantially more protection from destructive tsunami waves than do unhealthy or dead reefs, a Princeton University study suggests.
Stormy days ahead for coral reefs
The increasing violence of storms under global climate change will have major effects on coral reefs – and has important implications for their future management.
Coral reef was untouched by tsunami
Scientists say they've discovered a large coral reef off Thailand that was apparently undisturbed by the catastrophic December 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami.
Tsunami reef damage recovering
A year after the killer tsunami ravaged regions of Southeast Asia, scientists have documented the recovery of tsunami-affected coral reefs.
Illegal destruction of coral reefs worsened impact of tsunami
The illegal mining of corals off the southwest coast of Sri Lanka permitted far more onshore destruction from the 26 December2004 tsunami than occurred in nearby areas whose coral reefs were intact. This is the principal finding of a team of researchers from the United States and Sri Lanka who studied the area earlier this year.
Tsunami-damaged coral reefs should be left to recover naturally, say scientists
CORAL reefs damaged in the Asian tsunami tragedy should be allowed to recover naturally before countries launch into expensive restoration plans, according to some of the world’s leading scientists.
The scientists, led by a researcher from the University of Newcastle upon Tyne, and who set out their views in an advisory brief for the World Bank, point to historical records of major coral reef devastation by cyclones and typhoons, which show that reefs recovered without human intervention.
Predicting the next big wave
UQ engineer Hubert Chanson is working with world experts in coastal and river hydraulics to better predict tsunami damage of coastlines.
"There are a number of models to predict tsunami propagation in deep water but the recent experience and scientific data have shown that most tsunami models poorly predict flooding of coastal plains," Dr Chanson said.
Dr Chanson has teamed up with experts from Japan, California and New Zealand to produce a new mathematical model that will predict tsunami impacts on coastal towns.