Can You Legally Rip a DVD? Trial to Test 'Fair Use'

Wednesday's trial pitting DVD jukebox maker Kaleidescape Systems versus the agency responsible for DVD copy protection is expected to test the boundaries of fair use.

On Wednesday, a key copyright trial began in San Jose, as Kaleidescape Systems and the DVD Content Control Association went to court in a case expected to test the concept of "fair use".

Kaleidescape manufactures the Kaleidescape System, essentially a DVD jukebox, connected via Ethernet to a separate player box. Users can insert a DVD and rip it to the installed hard drive, for later viewing upon a television screen.

To the DVD CCA, the suit is a simple breach of contract of the terms of the Content Scrambling System, the encryption method that secures the millions of standard-definition DVDs sold worldwide.

To Kaleidescape, however, the question to be settled is a simple, more profound one: can a consumer who has legally purchased a DVD "rip" or copy it to a hard drive, to do with it what he wishes? A significant portion of Kaleidescape's defense will be the concept of "fair use," the portion of the U.S. Title code that governs broadcasts and rebroadcasts of commercial content within the home, hotels, and other functions, according to Michael Malcolm, the chief executive of the company.

Ironically, the Kaleidescape servers, which cost thousands of dollars, are a hit with the upper-crust Hollywood crowd, including actors – the type of people agencies like the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) has claimed has been negatively affected by piracy, Malcolm said. The DVD CCA, however, is made up of equal representation from the consumer-electronics, PC, and content camps, according to a CCA spokesman.

Both parties agree that in Sept. 2002, Kaleidescape took a license to use the CSS. In 2003, the DVD CSS "became aware" of the Kaleidescape System, according to court filings, and asked the company to better secure its product. It later employed a consultant who also served as an ombudsman between the two parties.

In 2006, the agency agreed to drop any claims for monetary damages, although it is asking the Superior Court of Santa Clara, Calif. to levy a permanent injunction against sales of the Kaleidescape system. In a countersuit, Kaleidescape has asked for monetary damages as well as a ruling that its products are in compliance with the terms of the licensing agreement.

Ripping is what "CSS… is intended to prevent"

According to William Coats of White and Case LLP, who is trying the case for the CCA, the Kaleidescape System violates the 100-page CSS license in several ways. The complaint lists five: failing to prevent the creation of digital copies of DVD content; a refusal to meet its obligation to "frustrate attempts to defeat CSS" in its hardware; selling any product that thwarts the CSS protections; a requirement to have the DVD disc in the drive "during authentication and playback"; and violating a prohibition to copy confidential CSS data.

As to the question of the requirement that a DVD be inserted into the drive during authentication, Coats said that "you just can't insert a drive onto the server and let it sit".

"Once the DVD content is copied onto a first System by auser, the actual DVD disc could be sold or otherwise provided to additional users to be copied onto other Systems, but with the content copied onto the first System remaining playable. This functionality constitutes a breach of the CSS License," the CCA's complaint reads.

Moreover, the mere act of copying the DVD "is precisely that which the CSS License is intended to prevent," the complaint adds. Continued...

The right to rip?

Malcolm, meanwhile, said his company has made every effort to comply with not only the CCA but other rights holders, including DVD Format/Logo Licensing Corporation, Dolby, Macrovision, DVI Promoters, HDMI Licensing LLC, Digital Content Protection, LLC (HDCP), MPEG LA, LLC, Nissim Corporation, Koninklijke Philips Electronics N.V. (acting for three different patent pools), and Toshiba Corporation (on behalf of the DVD Patent Licensing Group). The company will also argue that the CCA pulled out of the arbitration process before it ran its course.

Kaleidescape not only maintains the CSS protection as part of a bit-for-bit rip to the server, but also selectively applies 256-bit encryption to secure it further. An HDCP-equipped HDMI output jack is included on the back of the media player. "The content is safer in the Kaleidescape system than on the polycarbonate disc," Malcolm said.

Coats called that argument "irrelevant".

"We're completely in compliance with the terms of the - CSS - license," Malcolm said. "The thing that they would like to hang their hat is on is some wording that talks about 'authorized copies.' Clearly, their position is that there would be no authorized copies of DVD. In other words, the concept of 'fair use' does not apply to DVD."

The problem of "fair use"

The case has not received any amicus curiae briefs, typically filed if a case is seen by others as having broader applications that may affect their businesses. Malcolm said he has been in contact with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a non-profit legal agency that monitors issues of privacy and digital freedoms.

Fair use falls under Title 17 of the U.S. Code, and the majority of the code governs the rebroadcasts of visual and audio works via cable, satellite, and radio. Accepted usages of copying of recorded works under the "fair use" statutes have typically included criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research, according to the Copyright Office. The Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 permits non-commercial home recording of analog audio content for personal use, but says nothing about video.

When asked of whether he felt the case would have significant implications for fair use, Malcolm said he expected it would. "I think it very well could be," he said. "If we prevail, the case will certainly be a big step forward. If we lose, this case would be a big step backward and the studios would be a lot closer to establishing usage restrictions for DVDs."

The studios are even more worried about the implications for next-generation DVDs, whose copy protections include a "managed copy" provision, Malcolm said. With a good upscaling chip, a standard-definition DVD looks virtually identical to the high-definition content, he said.

Managed copy is a "model that they sell you the same content over and over for the rest of your life," Malcolm said. "HD DVD and Blu-ray's managed copies are simply a euphemism for charging you for every time you make a copy on the server."

Copyright 2007 by Ziff Davis Media, Distributed by United Press International

Related stories:

Big 3 mimic each other at E3: more, more and more
(AP) -- One word sums up the announcements made by the Big Three gaming companies at the E3 this week: more. During their flashy news conferences, Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony all announced plans for more games, more sequels, more exclusives, more connectivity and more ways for gamers to use their systems for stuff other than gaming.
Lenovo Launches Complete PC Solution for Small Businesses with New ThinkPad SL Notebooks
Lenovo today unveiled a complete computing solution for small-to-medium business (SMB) users that includes the new SL series of ThinkPad notebooks, value-added software and unique new services. The trio of notebooks – SL300, SL400 and SL500 - feature cutting-edge technologies, such as built-in high speed mobile broadband connectivity, excellent multimedia capabilities with an optional Blu-Ray DVD player on select models as well as a black glossy cover for a stylish design.
XBox 360 to stream Netflix movies
(AP) -- Microsoft Corp.'s Xbox 360 video game console will be able to stream thousands of movies over the Internet, thanks to a deal announced Monday with Netflix Inc. that highlights the way gaming devices are expanding into all-purpose home-entertainment hubs.
Intel Unveils 16 Next-Generation Processors, Including First Notebook Chips Built on 45nm Technology
Intel Corporation unveiled 16 products today, including the company's first 45 nanometer (nm) processors for Intel Centrino Processor Technology based laptops.
AMD Introduces Cutting-Edge PC Platform
Rewriting the rules for enthusiast computing, AMD today unveiled its new platform codenamed “Spider”, with the first true quad-core processor supporting scalable graphics for The Ultimate Visual Experience. The AMD Spider platform combines the introduction of AMD Phenom quad-core processors, ATI Radeon HD 3800 Series graphics processors with Microsoft DirectX 10.1 support, AMD 7-Series chipsets with CrossFireX and AMD OverDrive software. The AMD Spider platform is a major milestone on the path to Accelerated Computing, AMD’s vision for platform-level acceleration through co-processing.
Combined Expertise to Bring Wireless HDTV and Movies to Consumers
IBM and MediaTek Inc. today launch a joint initiative to develop ultra fast chipsets that can wirelessly transmit a full-length high definition movie to and from a home PC, hand-held device, retail kiosk or television set nearly as fast as a viewer can push their remote control.
LG Electronics Introduces LG Viewty Mobile Phone
LG Electronics, a worldwide technology leader in mobile communications, introduced its new LG Viewty, LG-KU990 mobile phone with advanced digital camera features and the ability to record video at up to 120 frames per second at IFA 2007 in Berlin, Germany.
Sony Unveils 4x Blu-Ray Disc Writer Drive
Sony Electronics today announced its second generation internal Blu-ray Disc (BD) writer drive for the computer aftermarket, which boasts 4X BD-R and 16X DVD+R recording speeds.

News discussion:

Can You Legally Rip A Dvd? in Technology news