Pediatricians say advice to obese kids and families falls on deaf ears

Pediatricians who talk to obese patients and their families about losing weight feel their conversation makes little difference in encouraging a lifestyle change, a small Saint Louis University study finds.

“Pediatricians feel as if their efforts are futile,” says Sarah Barlow, M.D., the lead author of the study who also is an associate professor of pediatrics at Saint Louis University School of Medicine and pediatric obesity specialist at SSM Cardinal Glennon Children’s Medical Center.

“Despite their best efforts to provide families with good advice, doctors find families lack the motivation or are so overwhelmed with the stresses of daily life that they don’t attempt to attack weight problems by eating healthier and exercising more.”

Findings were based on face-to-face interviews with eight St. Louis area pediatricians from diverse backgrounds and practice settings.

Those families who changed what they ate and how much they exercised typically came to appointments with a desire to lose weight and already were motivated to change their behavior.

“Doctors believe successful patients are motivated before they come to the door,” Dr. Barlow says.

“If clinicians can build on media attention and work to create motivation ahead of the visit and if they are prepared to provide answers to the families’ questions about healthy eating and activity practices, then clinicians may see more behavior change. Office visits need to get away from doctors saying ‘Here’s the problem, here’s what you need to do, goodbye until next year.’”

It’s difficult to change patterns of behavior, Dr. Barlow acknowledges.

“The pediatricians recognized that parents and children lack time for food preparation and physical activity. Low-income patients have many pressing needs. Other members of large households may undermine the parent’s control over the child’s food, and families may not have access to healthy food in their neighborhoods,” Dr. Barlow says.

“In addition to poor home environments in many families, doctors described low family commitment.”

Doctors identified obese children using standard height and weight charts instead of body mass index (BMI), which is a mathematically computed height/weight ratio that correlates with their amount of body fat.

“Doctors don’t think they need to calculate BMI because they can recognize the kids who are very obese,” Dr. Barlow says.

However, she says, doctors fail to diagnose children who may be starting to develop a weight problem and miss the chance to encourage families to make little lifestyle changes that are not so overwhelming.

“It’s a missed opportunity for these doctors to help address weight problems early on,” Dr. Barlow says. “If they’re going to have any effect at all, it’s going to be in encouraging small changes early.”


Source: Saint Louis University

Related stories:

Baby's smell tamps down dad's testosterone levels
Does eau de infant make dad a better parent? It does, it seems, if you are a common marmoset, a New World monkey known for its collaborative approach to rearing offspring.
Suicide risks studied in drugs for physical ills
(AP) -- Cody Miller was a high school football player who was allergic to ragweed. Douglas Briggs was a doctor coping with pain from an old back injury. Both are now dead, hanging victims driven to suicide, their families believe, when drugs prescribed to relieve physical symptoms upset their mental and emotional balance. Federal drug regulators are investigating to see if the families could be right.
Health of Afghan children jeopardized by family behaviors, not just war
Family values and ongoing conflict within the country are dramatically affecting the health of young children in Afghanistan. A study published in the open access journal BMC Public Health suggests that poor child health can be linked to a lack of maternal education and a lack of autonomy for mothers when seeking healthcare for their children. In addition, mothers who were married as children tend to have offspring with poorer health.
Newly-defined factors may prevent postpartum smoking relapse
Although many women quit smoking during pregnancy to protect their unborn children from the effects of cigarettes, half of them resume the habit within a few months of giving birth.
NBC's likely hit its peak with Phelps leaving
(AP) -- Can't Michael Phelps stay? Please? No amount of begging by NBC will make it happen. The Olympics swim meet ends soon after Phelps' bid for his eighth gold medal on NBC Saturday night, with another week of competition remaining.
Parents shape whether their children learn to eat fruits and vegetables
Providing fruits for snacks and serving vegetables at dinner can shape a preschooler's eating patterns for his or her lifetime.
Testosterone and body fat are controlled by the same genes
Genes that control percentage of body fat are also responsible for circulating levels of testosterone in men, research published in the latest edition of Clinical Endocrinology shows. The research shows a 23% overlap between the genes that control testosterone and those that regulate body fat composition, suggesting that these two variables are partly controlled by the same set of genes.
Gene produces hormones that lead to obesity
(PhysOrg.com) -- Obesity and common weight gain share a genetic basis. Professor Philippe Froguel, from Imperial College in Great Britain, and his team from the laboratoire Génomique et physiologie moléculaire des maladies métaboliques (CNRS/ Université Lille 2 / Institut Pasteur de Lille), in collaboration with teams from Inserm and Danish, Swiss and German partners, have discovered a new obesity gene that plays an essential role in the maturation of several key hormones that control food intake.

News discussion:

Medicine & Health news