Increasing the rate of return on a gift challenge does little to boost giving

A little encouragement makes a big difference in people’s motivation to give to a charity, but upgrading the encouragement doesn’t automatically boost giving, according to a University of Chicago study on the impact of matching gifts.

The authors of the study, John List, Professor of Economics at the University of Chicago, and Dean Karlan, Assistant Professor of Economics at Yale, also found that the donor’s political environment had a big impact on their responses to political appeals.

In studying how people respond to matching gifts, the scholars discovered that whether the donation match was three dollars to one, two dollars to one, or one dollar to one, the rate and amount of giving was the same. The expectation that their donation would increase the total support to the organization was apparently enough to motivate donors, they found.

“Simply announcing the match money is available considerably increases the revenue per solicitation — by 19 percent,” List said. “In addition, the match offer significantly increases the probability that an individual donates — by 22 percent.”

Their study is reported in the paper, “Does Price Matter in Charitable Giving? Evidence from a Large-Scale Natural Field Experiment” published in the December issue of the American Economic Review. The study is part of an emerging field in economics that looks at the “demand,” or asking side of fundraising. Most other work on fundraising has looked at the “supply side,” which examines the impact, for instance, of tax changes on people’s motivation to give.

Their work on matching gifts disputes many commonly held beliefs among professional fundraisers whose hunches about what motivates people to give has led them to think that increasing the return on matches automatically increases giving.

List and Karlan were able to test that assumption with a field experiment conducted with the cooperation of a liberal non-profit organization that works on social and policy areas related to civil liberties. The group regularly sends out mailings requesting donations, and the two scholars were able to perform a field experiment with one of their mailings.

In their experiment, the organization sent a mailing to more than 50,000 people who had given to them in the past. A control group, making up about a third of the group, received a mailing with no offer of a match. The remainder was divided evenly into groups that received different matching offers, including one to one, two to one and three to one.

The mailing raised $13,566 from the control group, $10,431 from the one-to-one match, $10,439 from the two-to-one match, and $10,423 from the three-to-one match for a total of $45,860.

Because the group is politically oriented, the scholars also wanted to see if the political environment of the donors’ communities had an impact on giving. The people who lived in states where George Bush had won the 2004 presidential election apparently felt a greater threat to civil liberty causes because they gave more in response to the match, the scholars found.

Regardless of their age, education, or income, donors in red states were much more sensitive to the match than those in blue states, the study showed. List noted that “much more work is necessary before we understand the exact mechanism at work in red and blue states, but the results of our study are consistent with other research in sociology, psychology, and economics that also shows people have a tendency to rally to support causes when they feel they are under some threat.”

Source: University of Chicago

Related stories:

Online Dating: Where Technology and Evolution Collide
When searching for a soul mate, you might think that the more options, the better. But the rise of technology – notably, the Internet – has thrown a wedge in that perception.
Microsoft releases beta version of Internet Explorer 8
Microsoft last week released a broadly available test version of its latest Web browser, Internet Explorer 8, including a tool to cover one's tracks across the Web.
Vine invasion? Ecologist looks at coexistence of trees and lianas
Among the hundreds of species of woody vines that University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee ecologist Stefan Schnitzer has encountered in the tropical forests of Panama, the largest has a stalk nearly 20 inches in circumference.
As Farmers' Markets Grow, So Should Management, Indicates OSU Study
Farmers' markets are rapidly growing in number in Oregon and throughout the United States and a key to their potential success can be found in how they approach growth and management, according to new research at Oregon State University.
Mind games: computer headset lets brain control action
It's mind over machine: a US high-tech company has created a headset allowing computer game lovers to use their thoughts to move mountains and make objects disappear on screen.
Size does matter: Researchers adapt drug dosing to body size
University of Queensland researchers are leading the charge in adapting drug dosing to a society that is changing shape.
Virtual human puts HIV drug to test
Harnessing the power of supercomputing, ‘grid’ technology and using a so-called ‘virtual physiological human’ (VPH), European researchers have simulated how well an HIV drug blocks a key protein in the lethal virus. The days of trial and error could be numbered.
Chemists identify compounds to lure nutria, a rat-like pest ravaging Gulf Coast wetlands
A 10-pound rodent pest called nutria ravaging southern wetlands in the US, which has been especially damaging to the marshland ecology in the Mississippi Delta following Hurricanes Rita and Katrina, may have finally met its match thanks to molecular science that includes the work of Professor Athula B. Attygalle, an expert in molecular chemistry and mass-spectrometry based at Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken, New Jersey, and a team of scientists from Cornell University and University of Iowa.

News discussion:

General Science news