Probing Question: Are Asteroids a Threat to Earth?

Hollywood thrillers such as Deep Impact helped to jump-start America's interest in knowing what our "deflection strategy" would be if a giant asteroid was on a potentially catastrophic collision course with Earth.

Chris Palma, senior lecturer in astronomy and astrophysics at Penn State, says that such events are statistically highly probable. "Throughout Earth's history, we have been bombarded by comets and asteroids from space," Palma notes. "Impacts happened more frequently in the past, but they will happen again. It is just a matter of when."

Explains Palma, a law was passed two years ago requiring NASA to "to both survey for near Earth objects and come up with a plan to divert those objects." Yet, some experts have criticized both NASA and the United States government for not doing enough to prevent potential impacts with Earth.

The so-called Tunguska event in 1908, believed to have been the only large-scale meteorite hit within recorded human history, reportedly flattened over 830 square miles of Siberia, with an explosion a thousand times more powerful than the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima. While it is staggering to imagine such damage in a heavily populated area, Palma cautions that "we have no experience with these scenarios and can't do more than estimate the number of lives that will be lost and the amount of damage to the infrastructure in the impact region."

Programs have been set into place to help predict and monitor threats posed by meteorite and asteroid impacts, such as NASA's Near Earth Object Program and University of Arizona's SpaceWatch group. However, Palma's impression is that the majority of similarly focused programs are spearheaded by "individual researchers."

What would happen if an asteroid was detected heading toward Earth? A number of different ideas have been proposed, says Palma, including "sending a very massive unmanned spacecraft towards the asteroid and using the ship's gravitational pull to nudge the asteroid off course." Adds Palma, the idea isn't to physically push it, but rather to use the spacecraft's strong gravitational pull to cause the asteroid to move into a different orbit without directly impacting the asteroid."

Would such a dramatic, heroic endeavor succeed? "My guess," says Palma," is that this particular model is a good theoretical starting point, but not one that is necessarily going to be feasible if applied."

Is enough being done to prepare for potential threats? As with so much else, it all depends on who you ask, though all agree that the stakes are high. After all, the most popular explanation for dinosaur extinction is the widespread after-effects of a giant asteroid impact.

Regarding our current state of deflection readiness, Palma says, "I think it is a bit of a stretch to say that NASA is doing nothing about this, but at the same time, I think you can argue that they should be doing more."

Source: by Josh Ambrose, Research Penn State

Related stories:

Near Earth Objects - what lies ahead?
Telescope facilities across the world are watching the skies for rocky remnants from outer space on a collision course with planet Earth. Currently one or two of these so called 'Near Earth Objects' [NEOs] are being recorded each day but fortunately for humankind the vast majority are the size of a human fist and pose no threat.
Coating copies microscopic biological surfaces
Someday, your car might have the metallic finish of some insects or the deep black of a butterfly's wing, and the reflectors might be patterned on the nanostructure of a fly's eyes, according to Penn State researchers who have developed a method to rapidly and inexpensively copy biological surface structures.
'Naked Eye' Gamma Ray Burst Was Aimed Squarely At Earth
(PhysOrg.com) -- The brightest explosion ever seen was observed in March this year. Now a team of astronomers from around the world, including the University of Leicester, the Mullard Space Science Laboratory of University College London and Liverpool John Moores University, have combined their data from satellites and observatories to explain what happened.
Butterfly wings may help scientists better understand photonic crystals
As technology moves forward, many scientists are looking to nature to find inspiration for the development of advanced materials that can have a variety of practical applications.
Scientists discover 10 new planets outside solar system
An international team of astronomers has found 10 new “extra solar” planets, planets that orbit stars other than our sun. The team used a system of robotic cameras that yield a great deal of information about these other worlds, some of which are quite exotic. The system is expected to revolutionize scientific understanding of how planets form.
Death of massive star creates brightest burst ever seen
Gamma-Ray Bursts are the most powerful explosive events in the Universe. They occur in far-off galaxies and so are usually faint. But on the morning of March 19th 2008 the Swift satellite found a burst which was so bright it could have been seen without binoculars or a telescope even though it was seven thousand times further away than the Andromeda galaxy.
Polarization technique focuses limelight
The ability to explore remote worlds in space has been enhanced through a polarization technique that allows the first ever detection of light reflected by extrasolar (exoplanet) planets. The study has been accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters.
Red sky at night -- astronomers delight
A collaboration of over 50 astronomers, The IPHAS consortium, led from the UK, with partners in Europe, USA, Australia, has released today the first comprehensive optical digital survey of our own Milky Way. Conducted by looking at light emitted by hydrogen ions, using the Isaac Newton Telescope on La Palma, the survey contains stunning red images of nebulae and stars. The data is described in a paper submitted to the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.

News discussion:

Space & Earth science news