Ahead of this weekend’s 2020 Summit academics from The Australian National University are warning research shows significant changes need to be made to Indigenous affairs policy to ‘close the gaps’ but the “narrative of failure” that dominates discussion on the area is unfounded.
The research undertaken by ANU academics Professor Jon Altman, Director of the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research and an attendee at this weekend’s summit, Fellow Dr Boyd Hunter and Research Fellow Nicholas Biddle has used, for the first time, available census data to chart likely timeframes for ‘closing the gaps’ between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians.
Among the findings are:
• Census data from 1971-2006 shows improvement in most social indicators, including percentage of people employed in the private sector, percentage with a post-school qualification and percentage who have never attended school. With current trends and policy, the ‘gaps’ between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians in these areas will be closed within 35 years.
• In other areas, such as male and female life expectancy, median income and unemployment rate, the gaps aren’t closing at all. Some measurements, based on current trends and policy, will take 2000 years before the gaps are closed.
• An examination of recent governments has found that the latter half of the Howard years (2001-2006) was more effective at ‘closing the gaps’ than either the first half (1996-2001) or the Hawke / Keating years of 1991-1996.
Lead author of the report Professor Altman said that the findings show that the picture on the successes and failures of Indigenous affairs policy is much more complex than widely thought.
“Using key indicators to measure employment status, income status, household size and home ownership, education and health status, we found that most socioeconomic outcomes are better now than 35 years ago. These results are at odds with the narrative of failure around Indigenous policy,” he said. “For other variables, including labour force participation, median income and home ownership our estimates indicate that closing the gaps will take much longer. For a number there is a divergence in outcomes, suggesting that the gaps will never close without significant policy changes.”
Professor Altman said that some big questions needed to be addressed at this weekend’s summit to put the country on the right road to closing the gaps. “The summit needs to address questions such as is there a need to confer commercially-valuable property rights alongside land and native title customary rights? And how do we learn from the successes of the past 35 years that have delivered much progress, but too slowly to meet national expectations?” he said.
The full paper and statistics are available here:
http://www.anu.edu.au/caepr/ClosingTheGaps.pdf
Source: Australian National University
Related stories:
Perspective: Policies must keep pace with genetic progress
Enactment of the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) of 2008 is a boon to individual patients and for genetic research, write Kathy Hudson, M.K. Holohan, and Francis Collins in the June 19 issue of the
New England Journal of Medicine. But the bill is not a panacea, they note: Employers, health insurers, patients, and doctors now must be educated about its provisions, gaps remain in genetic testing oversight, and there still may be opportunities to misuse genetic information.
Bunk beds pose dangers to kids and adults
Bunk bed-related injuries are not an issue of concern solely for parents of young children according to a study conducted by investigators at the Center for Injury Research and Policy of The Research Institute at Nationwide Children’s Hospital. The study, published in the June issue of
Pediatrics, found although three-quarters of the children who sustain bunk bed-related injuries are younger than 10 years of age, there is a surprising spike in injuries among individuals between the ages of 18 and 21 years.
Don't ask, don't tell: Financial disclosure lacking in literature on stents
Most published research about coronary stents does not reveal information about authors’ financial relationships that might bias their interpretation of scientific data, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center.
Restrictive drug policies often cause schizophrenic patients to discontinue medication
Policies requiring authorization before physicians can prescribe newer medications to schizophrenic patients may be counter-productive. According to a new study, patients in Maine’s Medicaid program who found themselves in this situation were 29% more likely to stop or disrupt medication use than patients not subject to the policy. In addition, although the policy was originally designed to cut costs, government savings were minimal at best. These findings are reported online in
Health Affairs.
Modern matron struggling to fulfil role as leader
Experts at The University of Nottingham say ‘modern matrons’ — with their managerial and entrepreneurial skills — are struggling to fulfil their role as leader, and this remains a major challenge in a crucially important area of healthcare.
Life expectancy rises for the educated; the less-educated reap no benefit
It's no secret that over the last few decades, life expectancy in the United States has been rising. However, recent data shows that not everyone has benefited from this encouraging trend. New findings from Harvard Medical School and Harvard University demonstrate that individuals with more than 12 years of education have significantly longer life expectancy than those who never went beyond high school.
Theory explains why 25 percent of cultures cut male genitals
Almost 25 percent of indigenous societies practice some form of male genital cutting, ranging from circumcision to the ritual removal of a testicle. The reason, reports a Cornell scientist, may be to reduce pregnancies from extramarital sex. More subtly, it could be to reduce conflict among men.
Gaps exist for adopting conflicts of interest policies among medical schools
A minority of U.S. medical schools surveyed have adopted policies on conflicts of interest regarding financial interests held by the institutions, while at least two-thirds have policies applying to financial interests of institutional officials, according to a study in the February 13 issue of JAMA.