Researcher Finds Teaching Moments in Hypocrisy

(PhysOrg.com) -- Jeff Stone, who has studied the issue of hypocrisy, says that people may feel compelled to change their behaviors when they realize that they became active advocates in their personal change.

No matter the number of advertisements and public messages promoting healthy habits, some people have a difficult time committing to them – even when those messages meld with their personal beliefs.

University of Arizona associate professor of psychology Jeff Stone – whose work involves motivating people to change their behavior – says the problem is in the human tendency toward hypocrisy.

Of course, nobody likes a hypocrite. But when it comes to issues of safe sex, exercise, dieting, sun protection, smoking and interpersonal relationships, Stone says hypocrites are everywhere.

Yet something does happen when a person realizes their own contradictions, he said.

As Stone explains, “In social psychology, there is a long history of research that shows discomfort motivates people to justify or rationalize their behavior by changing their attitude to say that what they did was not so bad.”

That sort of contradictory behavior piqued Stone’s interest and drove him to being studying the issue of hypocrisy while focusing on the topic of behavior.

He recently co-authored a chapter on dissonance theory – which states that people feel uncomfortable or stressful in situations where contradictions are evident – with Nicholas C. Fernandez, a doctoral degree candidate in the UA psychology department. The chapter, which also spoke about hypocrisy, was published last month in a book titled “Attitudes and Attitude Change.”

Stone, who heads up the Self and Attitudes Lab and the Social Psychology of Sport Lab at the UA, has spent nearly 20 years studying “cognitive dissonance” – the reaction people have when they experience a rift between the way they act and what they think or believe.

This serves as motivation to do something – whether it is to change one’s behavior or to change one’s mind about the issue.

Stone has determined that a teaching moment exists when a person experiences cognitive dissonance and that people aren’t called out on their contradictions nearly enough

“It’s about getting people to actively process messages in a way that leads to self-persuasion,” he said. “It’s a very active process.”

Stone, who has studied behaviors associated with safe sex and exercise, is now working with the Arizona Cancer Center to devise research programs that would hone in on those teaching moments, focusing particularly on smoking cessation and skin cancer prevention.

“We’re doing cancer prevention type studies with this research aimed at the issue of sun protection behaviors,” said Stone, who also serves as a research associate with the Arizona Cancer Center. “They’re the type of studies that are designed to get people to change their attitudes and to believe it is more favorable to use sunscreen.”

It’s not a matter of humiliating a person but “figuring out how to influence people,” he added. The key, he said, is to be privately reminded of the hypocrisy.

Stone also has published a number of articles on the topic, the most recent being an article, co-authored with Fernandez, that was published in Social and Personality Psychology Compass.

In the article, “To Practice What We Preach: The Use of Hypocrisy and Cognitive Dissonance to Motivate Behavior Change,” Stone and Fernandez analyzed some of the research surrounding cognitive dissonance that has been published around the world in recent years.

In their article, Stone and Fernandez wrote: “The dissonance and the need to restore consistency are induced by subsequently making people aware of the fact that they themselves have failed to practice the target behavior in the past. Mindfulness for past failures is accomplished by having people examine or generate a list of their reasons for not performing the behavior when they had the opportunity.”

When a person has the realization, the co-authors wrote, they begin to feel discomfort which then leads them to feel motivated to make a change.

One study in particular asked students to help develop an AIDS prevention and education program. During the process, students talked publically about important safe sex acts and half of them were later asked to write down their own personal behaviors. Others were also asked to video tape messages about safe sex.

“It’s really most effective when people publically advocate to people and allow people to discover on their own – or lead them to discover on their own – that they don’t perform the behaviors that they tell others to do,” Stone said.

The researchers found that those students who were realized that their words did not necessarily follow their actions were most likely to report that they would change.

This is tied to a person’s perceptions of self-integrity and also to honesty and sincerity. “Following a hypocritical act,” the co-authors wrote, “maintaining or restoring these perceptions of self-integrity requires that people act in a more honest and sincere manner than in the past. Thus, when they behave like a hypocrite, people become motivated to be honest and sincere about the norms for behavior, which is most directly accomplished by bringing their behavior into line with the proposed course for action.”

The research is important for several reasons, Stone said.

For instance, if a person leads a healthier life, that could potentially led to less stress on the health care system. If people conserved more, it could result in less pollution, Stone.

“One of the reasons for doing this kind of work,” he said, “is the applicability to making changes that benefit the person and society.”

Provided by University of Arizona

Related stories:

Early human populations evolved separately for 100,000 years
A team of Genographic researchers and their collaborators have published the most extensive survey to date of African mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Over 600 complete mtDNA genomes from indigenous populations across the continent were analyzed by the scientists, led by Doron Behar, Genographic Associate Researcher, based at Rambam Medical Center, Haifa, and Saharon Rosset of IBM T.J. Watson Research Center, NY and Tel Aviv University.
Earliest evidence for modern human behavior found in South African cave
Evidence of early humans living on the coast in South Africa, harvesting food from the sea, employing complex small stone tools and using red pigments in symbolic behavior 164,000 years ago, far earlier than previously documented, is being published in the Oct. 18 issue of the journal Nature.
Forensic photography brings color back to ancient textiles
Archaeologists are now turning to forensic crime lab techniques to hunt for dyes, paint, and other decoration in prehistoric textiles.
Theory of the sun's role in formation of the solar system questioned
A strange mix of oxygen found in a stony meteorite that exploded over Pueblito de Allende, Mexico nearly 40 years ago has puzzled scientists ever since. Small flecks of minerals lodged in the stone and thought to date from the beginning of the solar system have a pattern of oxygen types, or isotopes, that differs from those found in all known planetary rocks, including those from Earth, its Moon and meteorites from Mars.
Phoenix Mission Conducting Extended Activities on Mars
NASA's Phoenix Mars Lander, having completed its 90-day primary mission, is continuing its science collection activities. Science and engineering teams are looking forward to at least another month of Martian exploration.
Why is Greenland covered in ice?
There have been many reports in the media about the effects of global warming on the Greenland ice-sheet, but there is still great uncertainty as to why there is an ice-sheet there at all.
Playing video games offers learning across life span, say studies
Certain types of video games can have beneficial effects, improving gamers' dexterity as well as their ability to problem-solve – attributes that have proven useful not only to students but to surgeons, according to research discussed Sunday at the Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association.
Stone Age Graveyard reveals Lifestyles of a 'Green Sahara': Two Successive Cultures Thrived Lakeside
(PhysOrg.com) -- The largest Stone Age graveyard found in the Sahara, which provides an unparalleled record of life when the region was green, has been discovered in Niger by National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence and University of Chicago Professor Paul Sereno, whose team first happened on the site during a dinosaur-hunting expedition.

News discussion:

Medicine & Health news