Top grades not always needed to become a doctor

Top A-level results are not always necessary for students to succeed in medicine, according to the authors of a paper in this week’s BMJ. Students with average grades, who come from economically and educationally deprived areas, can do well at medical school provided they have extra academic and pastoral support during their first two years.

Becoming a doctor has traditionally been seen as the preserve of the professional middle classes—over three quarters of conventional medical students come from this background. Yet it is now acknowledged that the UK needs more doctors who better represent the diverse social and ethnic population of the country. As such, widening participation initiatives have become an important component of most UK Higher Education Institutions.

The paper, written by the academics behind such an initiative at King’s College London, analyses their success. The Extended Medical Degree Programme (EMDP) began in 2001. Its remit was to enable bright students from low-achieving state schools in Inner London to become doctors. Initially ten extra places were made available for these students each year and the first cohort graduated in 2007. To be accepted students needed to get CCC at A level, rather than the traditional AAB.

Students on the EMDP course are given an extra year of studying—the first two years of the traditional five year degree are spread over three—to allow for more academic and pastoral support.

Most of the students are the first in their family to go to university and come from different backgrounds from the majority of students. To help them adjust, EMDP students are also given extra support including an induction week, student mentors and personalised learning programmes.

Nine out of ten students so far accepted on to the EMDP programme are from ethnic minorities and just under a third (31%) from middle-class families. This compares with 51% and 76% respectively for students from “conventional” backgrounds.

The data shows that, despite the lower entry grades, the exam results of these students have been spread fairly evenly throughout the entire year group of 360–400 students. First time pass rates have generally been slightly lower for EMDP students, however in the clinical years (years 4–6) first time pass rates are identical for both conventional and EMDP students (93%). Of those who opted to do an intercalated BSc, 12% got a first, 76% an upper second and 12% a lower second, compared with 28%, 65% and 7% respectively among conventional students.

Over 200 students are now on this programme and doing well, so the authors say they can safely conclude that “medical students can succeed without AAB at A level” (as long as these results were obtained from a low achieving school) and as a result the widening participation programme is creating “a new type of doctor…[that] better reflects the social diversity of London’s population.”

In an accompanying editorial, Hugh Ip and Chris McManus discuss whether the more diverse population of doctors resulting from the widening participation initiative will better serve a diverse population of patients. They also question if the £190 000 spent each year on the EMDP programme is money well spent.

Source: British Medical Journal

Related stories:

Giving learning a personal touch
A learning system that adapts to the abilities and needs of students opens the way to a more personalised approach in delivering education electronically.
High intensity training helps heart patients
Cardiac patients from the community are benefiting from new exercise rehabilitation research at the University’s Exercise and Sport Science Division.
Engaging teachers means engaged students
To encourage and help teachers become more involved and enthusiastic about "inclusive teaching", the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) recently funded an action research based project. Action research can be explained as making changes and studying the impact of those changes in order to bring about an environment where students feel included in their learning process.
Messaging without barriers
Millions of people exchange electronic messages every day, but users of different systems often can’t reach each other. New European research promises to put them all in touch.
Profits for publishers in making books accessible to all
Many people have no access to most published books. European researchers are trying to remedy this by adapting new technologies to provide accessibility on demand for the visually impaired.
Powering up IT for professional learning
The study and implementation of technology-enhanced professional learning has been fragmented. Now European researchers have linked such ‘islands’ of knowledge into a thriving, collaborative community.
Does it matter that medical graduates don't get jobs as doctors?
In 2007, 1300 UK medical graduates were unable to secure training places, and this shortfall looks set to be repeated this year. But is this a betrayal of students’ expectations or is this inevitable if patients are to get the best care? Two experts debate the issue in this week’s BMJ.
Simulating surgery to reduce implant complications
A computer simulation breakthrough could mean fewer medical complications and better surgical outcomes for patients undergoing hip, knee or spinal implant surgery.

News discussion:

Medicine & Health news