Study suggests brain tumors need treatment with multiple 'targeted' drugs

Researchers at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute have shown that several, rather than just one, cell-growth switches are simultaneously overactive in many brain tumors and other solid tumors, explaining why treatment with just a single "targeted" switch-blocking drug often yields disappointing results.

The laboratory finding argues for quickly moving to clinical trials that combine three or more such targeted drugs for such cancers to shut down all the malfunctioning growth switches, according to the team led by Ronald DePinho, MD, director of the Center for Applied Cancer Science at the Dana-Farber. Their report is being posted online on Sept. 13 by the journal Science and will appear in a forthcoming print issue.

The switches are formed by molecules called receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) that often are mutated and hyperactive in cancer cells. Since a number of kinase-blocking drugs are already available -- Gleevec and Tarceva are two of the best-known -- the researchers said clinical trials of combinations of the compounds should be planned quickly.

"This is a transformative finding that will motivate clinicians and our pharmaceutical colleagues to design clinical trials with regimens using several inhibitors," said DePinho. He noted that in the laboratory study using cancer cell lines and fresh specimens of brain tumors, three or more kinase inhibitors were needed to quell the abnormal cell-growth signals.

The study focused on glioblastoma multiforme (GBM), an aggressive brain tumor that is nearly always fatal. The scientists also found similar patterns of multiply activated RTKs in other common cancers of the pancreas and lung.

Jayne Stommel, PhD, lead author of the report and a post-doctoral fellow in the DePinho lab, undertook a survey of molecular RTK "signaling pathways" in GBM cells to find the sources of abnormal growth.

RTKs are located on the surface of both normal and cancerous cells and receive signals from the cells' environment. Many of the signals are chemical "growth factors" directing the cell to divide and grow. Signals received by the RTKs are transmitted to the cell's nucleus via a pathway called PI3K, which often behaves abnormally in cancer cells.

At least 54 RTKs have been identified, and some, such as epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) have been implicated in glioblastomas. However, drugs that block EGFR have had limited success in delaying the progression of these and other virulent tumors. "Typically one elicits a positive initial response, but rarely durable cures," said DePinho, who is also a professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School. "Overall, the record of receptor tyrosine kinases inhibitors in these brain tumors has been somewhat disappointing."

Perhaps the problem was that other kinase pathways were also sending abnormal growth signals, acting as a redundant or backup source of growth simulation. "No one had looked to see how many receptor tyrosine kinases are activated at the same time in these cells," said Stommel.

The researchers tested 20 glioblastoma cell lines using an antibody array technique that measured the activation of 45 different RTKs at one time. In 19 of the 20 cell lines, three or more RTKs were activated at the same time, sending abnormal growth signals in triplicate to the nucleus. Moving from cell lines to fresh cells, the researchers saw the same multiple-RTK activity when they studied tumor samples from newly diagnosed patients.

The kinase inhibitor imatinib (Gleevec) had little effect on the errant signaling pathways when applied to the brain tumor cells. But when imatinib was given in combination with two other kinase inhibitors, erlotinib (Tarceva) and SU11274, traffic in the PI3K signaling pathway was eliminated, and the cancer cells died.

The study's findings "provide a rational explanation for the feeble clinical responses" when RTK inhibitors are given singly to patients with solid tumors, the investigators wrote, and suggest that combination therapy should yield better results.

In addition, patients' tumors can be profiled to identify which among the many RTK switches are activated, so that tailored therapy with the appropriate combination of inhibitors can be prescribed.

"This study provides proof of concept for the eventual implementation of a 'personalized' therapeutic paradigm in human cancer," the researchers concluded.

Source: Dana-Farber Cancer Institute

Related stories:

Researchers discover new enzyme in cancer growth
While studying the mechanics of blood clots, researchers at the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center discovered a new enzyme that not only affects the blood, but seems to play a primary role in how cancer tumors expand and spread throughout the body. The research appeared in recent issues of the journal Blood and the Journal of Thrombosis and Haemostasis.
Cellular senescence a double-edged sword
Scientists have identified a molecular cause behind the ravages of old age and in doing so have also shown how a natural process for fighting cancer in younger persons can actually promote cancer in older individuals. Cellular senescence, the process by which biological cells stop dividing in response to stress or damage to their DNA, was shown to trigger the secretion of proteins that cause inflammation in neighboring cells and tissue. Inflammation is linked to almost every major disease associated with aging, including many cancers.
Scientists probe limits of 'cancer stem-cell model'; Melanoma does not fit the model
(PhysOrg.com) -- One of the most promising new ideas about the causes of cancer, known as the cancer stem-cell model, must be reassessed because it is based largely on evidence from a laboratory test that is surprisingly flawed when applied to some cancers, University of Michigan researchers have concluded.
Broccoli compound targets key enzyme in late-stage cancer
(PhysOrg.com) -- An anti-cancer compound found in broccoli and cabbage works by lowering the activity of an enzyme associated with rapidly advancing breast cancer, according to a University of California, Berkeley, study appearing this week in the online early edition of the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Genetic breakdown in Fanconi anemia may have link to HPV-associated cancer
A genetic malfunction that causes DNA instability in people with the blood disorder Fanconi anemia may put them at high risk for squamous cell carcinomas linked to human papillomavirus (HPV), according to a study posted online ahead of print by Oncogene.
Curbing hormones' effects in obese patients could aid against breast cancer
Once-promising drugs that were abandoned in the fight against breast cancer still could be effective in obese patients, new research suggests.
Study unmasks how ovarian tumors evade immune system
Scientists at Johns Hopkins have determined how the characteristic shedding of fatty substances, or lipids, by ovarian tumors allows the cancer to evade the body's immune system, leaving the disease to spread unchecked. Ovarian cancer is considered to be one of the most aggressive malignancies, killing more than 70 percent of diagnosed women within five years, including an estimated 15,000 this year.
Prostate cancer spurs new nerves
Prostate cancer – and perhaps other cancers – promotes the growth of new nerves and the branching axons that carry their messages, a finding associated with more aggressive tumors, said researchers from Baylor College of Medicine in the first report of the phenomenon that appears today in the journal Clinical Cancer Research.

News discussion:

Targeted Drug Combos Could Outsmart Cancer in Medicine & Health news